For years, emphysema has been considered a smoker’s disease. But did you know polluted air can cause similar damage to the lungs? Emphysema is a chronic lung disease where the air sacs (alveoli) in the lungs are damaged and enlarged. The fine particulate matter found in polluted air can not just temporarily irritate your lungs, but it can also lead to long-term structural changes that are much like those seen in smokers. Many wonder: which one is worse for the lungs – the effects of air pollution or smoking?
Both air pollution and smoking cause serious damage, often via overlapping effects such as inflammation, reduced lung function, and lung tissue damage. So, while smoking is seen as a risk factor, it is becoming increasingly clear that breathing polluted air might be causing the same harm, one breath at a time. Let’s break it down to see how lungs are affected by smoking and by air pollution individually.
Understanding The Individual Impact
Air pollution and smoking both can damage the lungs and cause one or the other respiratory disease. While both can have some common symptoms like persistent coughing and lung irritation, understanding their individual impact is important.
Smoking and its effects
Cigarette smoke has a toxic mixture of over 7,000 chemicals, including tar, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, and benzene. [2] These toxins can inflame and scar lung tissues, weaken airways, and reduce the elasticity of skin & lungs.
Cigarette smoking is the number one factor responsible for approximately 90% of lung cancer cases and causes almost all of COPD. [1] Over time, the harmful chemicals in tobacco smoke can damage the lungs, reducing their natural recoil and making it harder to breathe. This can lead to chronic cough, swelling in the face or neck, and feeling weak or tired all the time. More serious symptoms may include jaundice, trouble walking, dizziness, or seizures.
Effects of Air Pollution
According to the Air Quality Life Index (AQLI), the effects of air pollution can shorten global life expectancy by nearly two years [3]. Long-term exposure to pollutants like fine particulate matter, metals, ozone, nitrogen dioxide, and organic compounds can lead to emphysema, asthma, reduced lung capacity, or any other lung-related health concerns. Also, a study published in JAMA revealed that even slightly elevated levels of air pollution can accelerate lung damage in people who have never smoked. [4]
91% of the world’s population lives in places where air pollution levels exceed WHO guideline limits. [5] People living in these places can also experience premature lung aging due to the effects of air pollution and its long-term exposure. In short, while smoking delivers an intense and concentrated dose of toxins, air pollution continuously exposes the entire population, making it a public health crisis.
Smoking or Air Pollution: Which One is Worse?
Comparing smoking and air pollution is not easy, as both can be deeply harmful. While a smoker can choose to quit, avoiding polluted air can be far more challenging.
Airborne toxins can continuously enter our respiratory system, damaging it gradually. Even nonsmokers living in urban areas with poor air quality can show higher chances of having a respiratory disease, cardiovascular problems, and premature mortality.
In short, smoking can be more toxic per puff, but the effects of air pollution can be more pervasive and unavoidable.
What Can You Do to Protect Your Lungs?
As it is said, it is better late than never. While you may not be able to control the air outside, you can definitely take steps to protect your lungs and limit exposure.
If You Smoke
Try to quit smoking. Quitting can be the most effective way to protect your lungs.
– If you are not able to quit, get help through counselling.
– Try using nicotine replacement products that can help you gradually quit smoking.
Explore Nicotine Replacement Products
If You Live In A Polluted City
– Use good-quality masks
– Limit outdoor activities whenever you can to avoid secondhand smoke.
– Keep an air purifier in your home and office spaces.
– Support environmental initiatives and public health policies targeting clean air.
For Everyone
– Stay physically active; this can improve your lung capacity.
– Eat antioxidant-rich food, as it can help combat inflammation.
– Stay hydrated; water can help clean the airways.
– Get regular checkups or lung function tests, especially if you experience coughing, wheezing, or shortness of breath.
Early Signs Your Lungs May Be Struggling
Your lungs often send subtle signals before a major problem develops – but they are easy to ignore. Watch out for these red flags that could mean your lungs are under strain:
- A persistent cough that lingers or worsens with time
- Wheezing
- Breathlessness even during light activity
- Chest discomfort or pain, especially when breathing deeply, laughing, or coughing
- A hoarse or changing voice
- Frequent respiratory infections like bronchitis or pneumonia
- Coughing up blood or discolored mucus (rust or brown tinges)
If you notice any of these symptoms, consult a doctor and consider getting a pulmonary function test to assess if your lungs are affected by smoking or air pollution.
Final Thoughts
Smoking and air pollution may take different routes – one by choice, the other by environment – but they lead to the same destination, that is, damaged lungs. Whether it is a cigarette or a city’s pollution, our lungs cannot tell the difference.
Protecting them starts with awareness – making small changes, taking personal steps to protect your lungs, and fighting for cleaner air. Because every breath counts.
Consult a Doctor Today and get to know about your health.
FAQs
Q. Is bad air quality like smoking cigarettes?
Yes, poor air quality can have similar effects on the lungs as smoking – both expose you to harmful particles and toxins that cause inflammation and oxidative stress. Breathing highly polluted air daily can slowly damage lung tissue, just like smoking over time.
Q. Is air pollution more dangerous than smoking?
It depends on the exposure. While smoking can deliver toxins directly into the lungs, chronic exposure to air pollution affects a much larger population and can shorten the global life expectancy, maybe sometimes more than smoking.
Q. How much AQI is equal to 1 cigarette?
There is no perfect comparison, but estimates suggest that breathing air with an AQI of above 100 (unhealthy) [6] for a full day may be roughly equivalent to smoking 1 cigarette.
Q. What are the first signs of lung damage?
Early signs may include a cough that lasts for a longer duration, wheezing, breathlessness, a hoarse or changing voice, chest discomfort, and frequent respiratory infections. Fatigue and reduced exercise tolerance can also appear as symptoms.
Q. Do all smokers have COPD?
No, not all smokers develop COPD – but smoking is the leading cause of it, causing around 85 to 90% of all COPD.
Q. Is vaping worse than smoking?
Vaping is often marketed as a safer alternative, but it is not risk-free. While e-cigarettes contain fewer toxic chemicals than tobacco smoke, they still deliver nicotine and harmful aerosols that can irritate and inflame the lungs. Therefore, it is best to avoid both vaping and smoking.
References
1. American Lung Association. 10 of the Worst Diseases Smoking Causes | State of Tobacco Control. https://www.lung.org/research/sotc/by-the-numbers/10-worst-diseases-smoking-causes.
2. American Lung Association. What’s in a cigarette? https://www.lung.org/quit-smoking/smoking-facts/whats-in-a-cigarette.
3. Air Quality Life Index (AQLI)
4. Aubrey A. Air pollution may be as harmful to your lungs as smoking cigarettes, study finds. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2019/08/13/750581235/air-pollution-may-be-as-harmful-to-your-lungs-as-smoking-cigarettes-study-finds. Published August 13, 2019.
5. Zhou G. Tobacco, air pollution, environmental carcinogenesis, and thoughts on conquering strategies of lung cancer. Cancer Biology and Medicine. 2019;16(4):700-713. doi:10.20892/j.issn.2095-3941.2019.0180
6. AQI
https://www.airnow.gov/aqi/aqi-basics/
(The article is written by Sneha Jajoo, Intern, Clinical Health & Content, and is reviewed by Dr.Subita Alagh, Assistant Team Lead, Disease Content.)
Recommended Reads
Rising H3N2 Influenza Cases: Symptoms, Risks, and How To Stay Safe
World Lung Day Special: Understanding the Health Risk of Ozone Pollution